The Church of the Highlands, led by Pastor Chris Hodges, has recently faced scrutiny over the purpose of The Lodge, a retreat center designed to help pastors recover from burnout.
Allegations have surfaced suggesting that the center may also be used to rehabilitate pastors accused of moral failings, including sexual misconduct.
Pastor Hodges has strongly denied these claims, asserting that The Lodge is solely focused on supporting pastors suffering from exhaustion and burnout, not those involved in ethical violations.
This article will explore the allegations, clarify misconceptions, and provide a clear understanding of The Lodge’s mission and the church’s stance on pastoral restoration.
Understanding the Purpose of The Lodge
A Safe Haven for Burnout Relief
The Lodge, opened in April 2023, is a $4.5 million retreat center located on the Church of the Highlands campus in Irondale.
Its primary mission is to provide a place for pastors and church leaders facing burnout to find rest, rejuvenation, and spiritual renewal.
According to Pastor Chris Hodges, the center is intended as a sanctuary where pastors can take a step back from their demanding duties, find peace, and re-energize themselves.
With four bedrooms and conference meeting rooms, The Lodge is equipped to host small groups of pastors and their spouses for extended retreats.
Burnout is a significant concern in the ministry, particularly following the COVID-19 pandemic.
Many pastors report feeling overwhelmed by the pressures of leading congregations through unprecedented challenges, and statistics indicate that 1 in 4 pastors is contemplating retirement or resignation by 2030 due to burnout.
Recognizing this problem, Hodges saw The Lodge as a necessary solution to help keep pastors mentally, emotionally, and spiritually healthy so they can continue their work in the church.
The Allegations and Misconceptions
Despite the positive mission, The Lodge became a topic of controversy when some former church staff members and outside observers speculated that it might be used to rehabilitate clergy accused of moral failures, including sexual misconduct.
This speculation arose due to Chris Hodges’ previous involvement in the restoration of pastors who had experienced moral failings.
Some critics began to question whether The Lodge was being used as a sanctuary for disgraced pastors rather than those merely experiencing burnout.
Pastor Hodges has vehemently denied these claims. In interviews with the media, he clarified that The Lodge is not and will never be a place for pastors accused of misconduct, including sexual assault.
He explained that his previous references to “pastoral restoration” applied specifically to pastors who were mentally and emotionally exhausted due to burnout—not those involved in moral failures.
Chris Hodges’ Role in Pastoral Restoration
A Decade of Involvement
Pastor Chris Hodges has been involved in restoring pastors who faced moral failures for over a decade.
His interest in this work stems from a genuine desire to help ministry leaders find healing after they have fallen short.
Hodges believes that, in certain cases, pastors can be restored to ministry if they are given the proper guidance, time away from leadership, and accountability structures.
In 2013, this philosophy became apparent when Hodges publicly announced the restoration process of Dino Rizzo, an associate pastor who had left his previous church, Healing Place Church, due to an inappropriate relationship.
Hodges worked with a group of overseers to design a comprehensive plan that required Rizzo to step down from ministry for a full year and undergo supervised ministry for another year before returning to leadership.
Hodges believed that with proper support and time, Rizzo could return to serving the church in a meaningful way.
The Case of Micahn Carter
A more recent case involving Micahn Carter sparked even more controversy. Carter, who was the pastor of Together Church in Yakima, Washington, stepped down in 2019 for undisclosed reasons.
He later joined the staff of Church of the Highlands, and Hodges agreed to help oversee his restoration process at the request of Carter’s previous church leaders.
However, after Carter had been at Church of the Highlands for some time, new allegations of sexual misconduct emerged, leading Hodges to immediately sever ties with Carter.
Hodges has since expressed regret for allowing Carter to preach at the Church of the Highlands while these allegations were unresolved.
He has made it clear that he and his church no longer wish to be involved in any restoration process for pastors accused of sexual misconduct, emphasizing that each case of pastoral restoration is unique, making it difficult to apply a single policy or approach.
ALSO READ: Learn to Sit Back and Observe. Not Everything Need – Tymoff
The Origins and Purpose of The Lodge
The Lodge as a Vision for Renewal
The Lodge was conceived long before the Carter case came to light, and Hodges has consistently stressed that it has no connection to restoring fallen pastors.
Its creation was inspired by the growing need for ministry leaders to have a place where they can escape the pressures of their roles, take time to reconnect with their families, and refocus on their spiritual mission.
During the height of the pandemic, Hodges personally counseled approximately 20 pastors who were on the verge of quitting.
These pastors, like many others across the world, were grappling with unprecedented levels of stress as they navigated leading their churches through a global crisis.
Many of them were burnt out and emotionally drained but had not committed any moral failings.
Hodges’ vision for The Lodge was to offer a peaceful retreat for pastors like these—leaders who simply needed a break to recharge their spirits and continue their work in the ministry.
The Lodge is designed to host small groups of pastors and their spouses for five-day retreats, offering them opportunities to rest, worship, and participate in couple-oriented activities such as date nights.
The ultimate goal is to ensure that pastors return to their congregations refreshed and ready to continue their important work.
Debunking the Stigma: Misunderstanding the Mission
Despite Hodges’ clear explanations, the stigma surrounding The Lodge persists. Some critics continue to associate the center with the restoration of pastors who have committed moral failings, particularly due to the timing of the Micahn Carter case.
Hodges acknowledges that this coincidence may have contributed to the confusion but is determined to break this misconception.
He has made it clear that The Lodge was never intended to address cases of sexual misconduct or other moral failings.
The church’s website features a comprehensive overview of The Lodge, describing it as “a place where pastors and ministry leaders can be hosted, refreshed, rejuvenated, and refocused on their calling, so they can continue to spread the Gospel to the ends of the earth.”
The description emphasizes that The Lodge is responding to the alarming rise in pastoral burnout, with many church leaders at risk of leaving their ministries due to exhaustion. Hodges hopes that The Lodge will help prevent this crisis by offering much-needed support.
The Association of Related Churches (ARC) and Misconceptions
As co-founder of the Association of Related Churches (ARC), Chris Hodges has also had to clarify the organization’s role in supporting churches.
ARC helps launch new churches across the country by providing training, resources, and funding. However, ARC does not have governance over the churches it assists.
Each church that is part of the ARC network is independently governed, with its own elder board responsible for decisions and leadership.
Many critics mistakenly believe that ARC has the power to intervene in the internal affairs of its member churches, but this is not the case.
Hodges has reiterated that ARC does not have authority over the churches it supports and cannot dictate their operations or leadership decisions.
This misunderstanding has further contributed to confusion about the role of The Lodge and the Church of the Highlands in handling pastoral restoration.
ARC’s Commitment to Church Growth
Despite these misconceptions, ARC remains an important player in helping new churches thrive.
By providing resources and support to newly planted churches, ARC helps ministry leaders navigate the challenges of starting a congregation and building a community.
Hodges’ involvement in ARC reflects his broader commitment to supporting pastors and ensuring they have the tools and resources they need to succeed in their ministries.
The Church’s Media Response and Public Perception
As the controversy around The Lodge and the Church of the Highlands gained momentum, Chris Hodges expressed dissatisfaction with how the church had been portrayed in the media.
According to him, the misinterpretations of The Lodge’s purpose and its connection to his involvement in restoring fallen pastors have unfairly shaped public perception.
Hodges believes the media has been biased at times, further fueling misunderstandings about the church’s true intentions.
He cited the fact that the church had initially refrained from commenting on The Lodge’s purpose to avoid giving further ground for speculation.
However, as the narrative continued to spiral, Hodges decided to release a video in April 2023, coinciding with the opening of The Lodge, explaining its true purpose.
The video, which is now featured on the church’s website, clarifies the role of The Lodge as a retreat center aimed at combating burnout, not a place for restoring pastors involved in sexual misconduct.
The Future of The Lodge: A Vision of Pastoral Renewal
Plans for Program Development
Though The Lodge is already functioning as a retreat center, with guest speakers staying at the facility for church events, its long-term vision is still a work in progress.
Chris Hodges envisions developing comprehensive programs that will directly address the needs of pastors and their spouses who are struggling with burnout.
His goal is to provide structured retreats where these leaders can spend five days in a peaceful environment, away from the pressures of their ministry work, and focus on spiritual and emotional renewal.
Currently, The Lodge does not have dedicated staff or formal programs specifically targeting pastoral burnout, but Hodges is committed to building these resources over time.
The plan is to create retreats that involve counseling, worship sessions, and activities designed to help pastors reconnect with their families and refocus on their spiritual missions.
These programs will emphasize mental health and spiritual well-being, recognizing that pastors face unique pressures in their roles.
Tackling Pastoral Burnout: The Importance of Support
Pastoral burnout is a growing crisis in many churches around the world, and the Church of the Highlands is not alone in recognizing this issue.
According to recent surveys, a significant percentage of pastors are considering leaving ministry due to stress, isolation, and exhaustion.
The pandemic exacerbated these issues, with many pastors reporting feelings of loneliness, anxiety, and a lack of support.
These leaders are responsible not only for the spiritual well-being of their congregations but also for the administrative, financial, and personal challenges that come with running a church.
Hodges believes that The Lodge can play a crucial role in addressing this problem by offering pastors a place to rest and rejuvenate before they reach the point of burnout.
His vision is that pastors will leave The Lodge feeling spiritually recharged and emotionally supported, allowing them to return to their congregations with renewed energy and focus.
Misconceptions About the Church’s Approach to Pastoral Restoration
Clarifying the Role of The Lodge
Much of the confusion surrounding the Church of the Highlands and The Lodge stems from a misunderstanding of the church’s role in pastoral restoration.
While Hodges has been involved in helping pastors who experienced moral failings in the past, The Lodge itself was never designed for that purpose.
Instead, it is meant to support pastors who are struggling with burnout or exhaustion but have not committed any moral or ethical violations.
Hodges has made it clear that he no longer wishes to be involved in cases where pastors are accused of sexual misconduct.
The church’s experience with the Micahn Carter case, in particular, solidified this stance.
After Carter was accused of sexual assault, Hodges and his church severed ties with him immediately, and Hodges later expressed regret for allowing Carter to preach at the Church of the Highlands.
This case, however, had no connection to The Lodge, and Hodges is determined to distance the center from any association with restoring pastors involved in moral failings.
No Universal Restoration Program
Another important point of clarification is that the Church of the Highlands does not operate a universal program for pastors accused of moral failings.
Hodges explained that each case of pastoral failure is unique, making it difficult to create a standard policy for restoration.
In some cases, pastors may be able to return to ministry after a period of rehabilitation, as was the case with Dino Rizzo.
In other cases, such as with Micahn Carter, the nature of the allegations may prevent a return to ministry altogether.
Hodges also emphasized that the church’s involvement in pastoral restoration is not the same as offering a free pass for pastors who have committed serious moral transgressions.
Instead, the church has taken a measured approach, ensuring that any restoration process involves accountability, time away from leadership, and counseling.
| Misconception | Clarification |
|---|---|
| The Lodge is used for restoring pastors involved in moral failings | The Lodge is intended for pastors suffering from burnout, not those involved in misconduct. |
| The Church of the Highlands operates a program for pastors with moral failings | There is no universal program; each case of pastoral failure is unique. |
| ARC has governing authority over its member churches | ARC supports new churches but has no governance authority over them. |
| The Lodge was connected to the Micahn Carter case | The Lodge has no connection to the Micahn Carter restoration process. |
Conclusion: Unraveling the Truth Behind the Church of the Highlands Exposed
The controversy surrounding the Church of the Highlands exposed narrative has revealed deep misunderstandings about the church’s operations and the purpose of The Lodge.
Despite initial speculation, it is clear that The Lodge is not a place for restoring pastors accused of moral failings.
Instead, it serves as a retreat center dedicated to helping pastors and church leaders recover from burnout and continue their important work in ministry.
Through careful clarification and commitment to transparency, Chris Hodges has worked to dispel the misconceptions surrounding his church and The Lodge.
As the Church of the Highlands moves forward, it remains focused on its mission to support pastors in need, ensuring they have the strength and spiritual guidance to lead their congregations with renewed energy.
